Dušan Fuštar
Душан Фуштар
Born (1954-06-29) 29 June 1954 (age 71)
Known forcrimes against humanity
Convictionpersecution as a crime against humanity
Criminal charge
murder, torture, sexual violence, other inhumane acts, and persecution (as crimes against humanity)
Penalty
nine years' imprisonment
Capture status
surrendered
Details
VictimsNon-Serb detainees from the Prijedor region
CountryBosnia and Herzegovina
LocationKeraterm concentration camp
Date apprehended
31 January 2022

Dušan Fuštar (born 29 June 1954) is a Bosnian Serb who was found guilty by the Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina (Court of BiH) of persecution  constituting crimes against humanity under the criminal code of Bosnia and Herzegovina  committed at the Keraterm concentration camp near Prijedor, Bosnia and Herzegovina, during the Bosnian War.

Fuštar was born in Bačko Dobro Polje, Vojvodina, Yugoslavia, and worked as a mechanic. The Bosnian War broke out in April 1992, and in late May the Keraterm camp opened. It held almost exclusively non-Serb detainees from the surrounding districts who had been rounded up during the ethnic cleansing of central Bosanska Krajina. The detainees were kept in deplorable conditions and an atmosphere of severe physical and psychological violence, and had limited access to inadequate and poor quality food, water and medical care. Between June and August 1992, while leader of one of three guard shifts at the camp, Fuštar failed to assert his authority while on duty and to the extent of his ability, to protect the detainees. He also failed to improve the living conditions of detainees, and thereby contributed to and furthered the system of ill treatment and persecution under the joint criminal enterprise which the camp constituted. The Keraterm camp closed in early August.

Fuštar was indicted by the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) in July 1995. On 31 January 2002, he surrendered to the authorities of Bosnia and Herzegovina and was transferred into ICTY custody. In the meantime, prosecutions of some of those indicted for alleged crimes at Keraterm had proceeded, and a new Keraterm case had been formed. Fuštar entered pleas of not guilty to all counts under the operative indictment. In April 2006, the ICTY referral chamber decided to transfer the prosecution of Fuštar and his co-accused Željko Mejakić, Dušan Knežević and Momčilo Gruban to the Court of BiH as part of the process of the ICTY concluding its mandate. They were then indicted with crimes against humanity by the prosecutor of Bosnia and Herzegovina and entered not guilty pleas. Their trial began in December 2006. In March 2008, Fuštar entered into a plea agreement with the prosecutor on the basis of an amended indictment comprising one count of crimes against humanity of persecution, and the court separated Fuštar from the case and accepted the plea agreement the following month. On 22 April he was found guilty of the single count of crimes against humanity on the basis of his participation in the JCE, and sentenced to nine years' imprisonment. At the hearing he read a statement of remorse in which he denied personally assaulting or harassing any detainees, but expressed his "deepest remorse" to the detainees who had been hurt in any way at the camp. His custody was extended by the at the hearing but he was released conditionally on 26 May by order of the appellate panel on the basis that he had already served two-thirds of his sentence. His release was protested by the Prijedor-based womens' non-governmental organisation IZVOR and victims. In May 2008 the court found his three co-accused guilty of crimes against humanity.

Early life and work

edit

Dušan Fuštar was born on 29 June 1954 in Bačko Dobro Polje, Vojvodina, Yugoslavia.[1] He is of Bosnian Serb ethnicity,[2] and worked as a mechanic.[3]

Establishment of concentration camps at Prijedor

edit
Location of Prijedor and Banja Luka within Bosnia and Herzegovina

In September 1991, as Yugoslavia continued to break up, several Bosnian Serb autonomous regions were proclaimed in Bosnia and Herzegovina, which then each established what was known as a crisis staff. Each crisis staff consisted of the leaders of the Bosnian Serb-dominated Serb Democratic Party (SDS), the local Yugoslav People's Army (JNA) commander, and Bosnian Serb police officials. Initially the Serb Autonomous Region of Krajina (ARK) did not include the Prijedor municipality  which incorporated the town itself and some outlying villages. Before the war, the population of the municipality was 44 per cent Bosnian Muslim, 42.5 per cent Bosnian Serb, 5.6 per cent Bosnian Croat, with the rest identifying as Yugoslav, Ukrainian, Russian or Italian. Within the municipality the local government was run by the Bosnian Muslim-dominated Party of Democratic Action (SDA), which had a small majority. On 30 April 1992, the SDS, assisted by police and military forces, took over the town of Prijedor, and JNA soldiers occupied all the prominent institutions in the town. A local crisis staff was created, reporting to the ARK crisis staff in the city of Banja Luka 50 km (31 mi) to the east.[4] Immediately after the Bosnian Serb takeover of the municipality, non-Serbs were targeted for abusive treatment.[5] After the JNA elements in Bosnia and Herzegovina became the Bosnian Serb Army (VRS) on 20 May, majority non-Serb villages in the Prijedor area were attacked by the VRS, and the population rounded up, although some fled. This occurred in Prijedor town itself on 30 May. Older men, and women and children were separated from men of fighting age, who were transported to the police station in Prijedor then bussed to either the Omarska or Keraterm concentration camps. The elderly men, women and children were generally taken to the Trnopolje concentration camp. All three camps were in the wider Prijedor municipality. Non-Serb community leaders were included in the roundup and sent to one of the camps.[6][7]

Fuštar's activities at the Keraterm concentration camp

edit
The Keraterm concentration camp was established in a former ceramics factory near Prijedor.

The Keraterm camp was located at a former ceramic factory in the suburb of Čirkin Polje in Prijedor, and operated from 24 May to 5 August.[8] Keraterm only held a small number of female detainees, and most of the 1,000 to 1,500 people held there were Bosnian Muslim men, with a few Bosnian Croats. The detainees were kept in inhumane conditions and subjected to psychological and physical abuse, and many were tortured and/or killed. The detainees were continuously exposed to severe beatings by the members of the camp guard force, which consisted of reserve police officers from Prijedor, and by visitors to the camp,[8][9] using "fists, feet, knives, bats and other objects". Inspectors visited the camp in the mornings and interrogated detainees  this also involved beatings, some of which were fatal.[8] Detainees were also subjected to violent sexual assault, and hundreds of crimes were committed in the camp.[10]

Between June and August 1992, while leader of one of three guard shifts at the camp, Fuštar failed to assert his authority while on duty and to the extent of his ability, to protect the detainees. He also failed to improve the living conditions of detainees, and thereby contributed to and furthered the system of ill treatment and persecution in the camp.

On 7 August 1992, the British journalist Ed Vulliamy reported on the shocking conditions in the Omarska and Trnopolje camps, having visited them in the preceding days at the invitation of the president of the self-proclaimed Bosnian Serb proto-state, Republika Srpska, Radovan Karadžić.[11] The international outcry that arose from Vulliamy's reporting and photographs of emaciated detainees caused the Bosnian Serbs to close the Omarska camp soon after, although many of the detainees were just moved to other camps.[12]

Indictment, surrender and transfer of case to Bosnia and Herzegovina

edit
Fuštar was indicted by the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia in February 1995

In 1993, the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) was established by the United Nations (UN) to prosecute war crimes that took place in the Balkans in the 1990s.[13] In July 1995, Fuštar, along with 12 other persons allegedly involved in the running of the Keraterm camp, was indicted by the ICTY under Case Number IT-95-8.[14] On 20 December 1995, the Bosnian War ended when the Dayton Agreement came into force, along with the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO)-led multi-national peace enforcement operation known as the Implementation Force (IFOR). After a year during which the peace agreement between the former warring parties was successfully implemented, the NATO-led Stabilisation Force (SFOR) took over on 20 December 1996.[15] In December 2004, SFOR was succeeded by the European Union Force Bosnia and Herzegovina (EUFOR) which continued to oversee the military implementation of the Dayton Agreement.[16]

On 5 May 1998, the ICTY prosecutor withdrew the charges against five of the accused over the operation of the Keraterm camp under Case Number IT-95-8. As a result, the amended Keraterm indictment included only Fuštar, Dušan Knežević, Predrag Banović, and five others. The prosecutor stated that the withdrawal of these accused people from the indictments resulted from a re-evaluation of the investigative and prosecutorial strategies of the ICTY to prioritise the most serious cases, and the fact that none of those against whom charges had been withdrawn had yet been arrested or surrendered to the court, increasing the anticipated number of separate trials.[17] On 9 November 1998, the ICTY announced that its prosecutor had been granted leave to withdraw four accused from the amended Omarska and Keraterm indictments and consolidate their charges under a single and separate indictment.[18] The indictment in the Keraterm case was amended in August 1999 and again in January 2001. Because only three of the accused from the Keraterm indictment were in custody at this time, a trial of these three under Case Number IT-95-8 commenced in March 2001 and was completed in November 2001.[19] In the same month as that trial concluded, Banović was transferred to ICTY custody[20] and a new Keraterm case was established under Case Number IT-95-8/1, in which he was included. When Fuštar was transferred into ICTY custody on 31 January 2002,[21] he was joined to the new case. he entered pleas of not guilty to all counts of the indictment.[22]

In September 2002, the remaining three accused on the original Omarska indictment Case Number IT-95-4 (Knežević, Mejakić and Gruban) were joined to those accused in the new Keraterm indictment Case Number IT-95-8/1 (Knežević, Banović and Fuštar) and a new consolidated case was created against Case Number IT-02-65.[23] On 21 November 2002 this consolidated indictment became the operative ICTY indictment against the five co-accused.[23] In June 2003, Banović came to a plea agreement with the prosecution and was withdrawn from the operative indictment and dealt with separately.[24] On 1 July 2003, Mejakić surrendered to the authorities of Serbia and Montenegro and was transferred into ICTY custody.[24][25]

The operative indictment comprised the following counts against Fuštar on the basis of individual responsibility under Article 7(1) and command responsibility under Article 7(3) of the ICTY statute:[22][23]

  • Count 1 – Persecutions on political, racial or religious grounds, a crime against humanity  Article 5(h)
  • Count 2 – Murder, a crime against humanity  Article 5(a)
  • Count 3 – Murder, a violation of the laws or customs of war  Article 3
  • Count 4 – Inhumane acts, a crime against humanity  Article 5(i)
  • Count 5 – Cruel treatment, a violation of the laws or customs of war  Article 3

On 7 April 2006, the ICTY announced that its appeals chamber had upheld a decision to transfer the prosecution of Fuštar, Knežević, Mejakić and Gruban to the Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina (Court of BiH) under ICTY Rule 11bis.[26] In 2005, as part of the process of concluding its mandate pursuant to resolutions of the United Nations Security Council, the ICTY had begun transferring middle and lower-level indictees to the courts of the countries of the former Yugoslavia. Such transfers were subject to various conditions. On 9 May 2006, the case against Fuštar, Knežević, Mejakić and Gruban was transferred to Bosnia and Herzegovina for trial,[27] and they were all transferred into the custody of Bosnia and Herzegovina on the same day.[28] From this point on, the ICTY monitored proceedings at the Court of BiH and received regular progress reports from the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe's mission to Bosnia and Herzegovina on the prosecution, sentencing and appeals.[29] From this point on, the ICTY monitored proceedings at the Court of BiH and received regular progress reports on the prosecution, sentencing and appeals.[29]

Trial, sentencing and appeal

edit

On 7 July 2006, the prosecutor of Bosnia and Herzegovina issued an indictment charging Knežević, Mejakić, Gruban and Fuštar with crimes against humanity. Knežević was indicted for the following crimes at the Omarska camp under various subparagraphs of Article 172(1) of the Criminal Code of Bosnia and Herzegovina, namely:[30]

  • (a) depriving another person of his life (murder);
  • (e) imprisonment (arbitrary and unlawful confinement of camp detainees);
  • (f) torture (beatings and other physical abuse);
  • (g) sexual violence (rapes and other forms of sexual abuse);
  • (k) other inhumane acts (confinement in inhumane conditions, harassment, humiliation and other psychological abuse); and
  • (h) persecution.

Knežević was also indicted for the same crimes at the Keraterm camp under the same subparagraphs of Article 172(1) of the Criminal Code of Bosnia and Herzegovina, except subparagraph (g).[30] The indictments against Knežević were confirmed by the Court of BiH a week later. On 28 July 2006, all four accused pleaded not guilty. The trial commenced on 20 December 2006.[31][32] The court separated Fuštar from the case on 17 April 2008 as he wished to enter into a plea agreement. The trial of Knežević, Mejakić and Gruban continued, and the court rendered its first instance verdict on 30 May 2008.[31]

Knežević was found guilty of all the crimes against humanity under article 172(1) with which he had been indicted. This finding was on the basis of individual responsibility,[33][34] and also under the JCE directed at “forcefully removing, detaining, and harassing the non-Serb population” of Prijedor.[2]. He was sentenced to long-term imprisonment[a] for 31 years. His co-defendants were also found guilty of crimes against humanity. Knežević appealed the first instance verdict, claiming that there had been violations of the Criminal Code, the Criminal Procedure Code, and in the establishment of facts.[33][34]

On 20 July 2009, the appellate panel of the Court of BiH rendered its final and binding verdict in the case, described by the OSCE as "deemed generally as a clear and well-structured decision". The panel revised the basis of Knežević's conviction, stating that the basis for his criminal liability was under the JCE, which, as the broadest form of responsibility, encompassed any individual liability.[33][36] The panel confirmed Knežević's conviction and sentence.[37] The court worked under the assumption that Knežević's motive was that he was trying to find information about the individual who had killed his brother during the war,[38] and found that Knezevic’s responsibility for the crimes he committed was not diminished because he wished to commit the crimes “in an extremely cruel way.”[39] The OSCE observed that the appeal panel in this case had clarified several previously unsettled aspects of the domestic law of Bosnia and Herzegovina regarding JCE. Firstly, that JCE could legally be applied to domestic war crimes prosecutions, and also how JCE should relate to direct and command responsibility for crimes.[40]

On 24 July 2009, Knežević began his sentence at the Penal Correctional Institution in Foča, the only facility in the Republika Srpska entity of Bosnia and Herzegovina that can house prisoners serving sentences of long-term imprisonment.[40]

Notes

edit
  1. "Long-term imprisonment" is the most severe criminal sanction prescribed in the criminal law of Bosnia and Herzegovina. It is a special form of imprisonment, the term of which can range from 20 to 45 years. In comparison to “ordinary imprisonment", a slightly different regime applies to it (e.g. concerning punishment in conjunction, suspended sentence, pardon etc.). It is prescribed for the gravest forms of serious criminal offences perpetrated with intent. Under existing regulations, this punishment is prescribed for criminal offences against the integrity of the state and for crimes against humanity and values protected by international law.[35]

Footnotes

edit

References

edit

Books, conference papers and reports

edit

News and websites

edit