Talk:Provincias Internas

Latest comment: 6 months ago by WCCasey in topic Better maps needed

Humboldt a credible source?

edit

A recent edit to the "Society" section adds a number of statements sourced to the writings of Alexander von Humboldt. I doubt the accuracy of at least one of those assertions: "According to Humboldt, Spanish and Criollo people comprised the majority of the inhabitants in the Provincias Internas by 1810. This was caused by the arrival of more waves of new Spanish settlers, racial segregation among castes and especially by a catastrophic decrease in numbers of the indigenous peoples."

Looking at the 1790 demographics, such a major shift seems unlikely in those 20 years. Also, I haven't yet read the Humboldt source, so can't say whether or not the article text is an accurate summation of Humboldt's views. Either way, I'd like to see a more recent and authoritative source for this assertion. WCCasey (talk) 18:46, 17 March 2015 (UTC)Reply

Better maps needed

edit

The map captioned "New Spain in 1819..." shows two areas labeled "Provincias Internas", which was a later east-west division of the single polity described in this article. A relevant map for this position in the "History" section should be from a year closer to when Galvez' reorganization first happened, before the east-west split. This map should move3 down to replace the one labeled "1817 Spanish Map . . ." (illegible at its small size) in the "New Division" subsection. WCCasey (talk) WCCasey (talk) 16:07, 15 December 2025 (UTC)Reply