Talk:Girtys Run

Latest comment: 10 months ago by Alekjds in topic "Girty's Run" or "Girtys Run"

Neutrality of the term "famous renegade"

edit

Currently the article refers to Simon Girty as a "famous renegade". I wouldn't refer to him as a "famous Canadian patriot", so I request American contributors tone it down as well.

How about something like "influential frontier figure"? Geo Swan (talk) 16:54, 7 January 2020 (UTC)Reply

"Girty's Run" or "Girtys Run"

edit

I'm assuming that the article title lacks an apostrophe because that's how USGIS has the name catalogued; likewise Google Maps has it without the apostrophe. A quick search of the Post-Gazette catalog from 1990 to present seems like a 60–40 split in favor of keeping the apostrophe. My proposal, unless anyone disagrees, is to rename the article Girty's Run and in the lede write Girty's Run (or Girtys Run), and keep the more natural English apostrophe form throughout the article as it is currently. Alekjds (talk) 22:57, 9 August 2025 (UTC)Reply