| Discussion Topic | Replies (estimated) | Archive Link |
|---|
| Update | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Update |
| Banu Qurayza had it coming? | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Banu Qurayza had it coming? |
| Intro section | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Intro section |
| Assessment comment | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Assessment comment |
| Secular historians | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Secular historians |
| Removal | 5 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Removal |
| Unsourced statement | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Unsourced statement |
| Directory of Sites Critical of Muhammad | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Directory of Sites Critical of Muhammad |
| Why does the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) get criticism and not other religious figures? | 5 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Why does the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) get criticism and not other religious figures? |
| quote for Arrow740 | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#quote for Arrow740 |
| Added quote from Hirsi calling him a "perverted tyrant" | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Added quote from Hirsi calling him a "perverted tyrant" |
| name change | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#name change |
| This Article Does Not Seem Proper | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#This Article Does Not Seem Proper |
| This article needs a lead | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#This article needs a lead |
| Needs sourcing | 5 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Needs sourcing |
| Why Prophet Muhammad gets criticism and other religious figures do not! | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Why Prophet Muhammad gets criticism and other religious figures do not! |
| FFI and POD | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#FFI and POD |
| Why isn't Voltaire mentioned? | 10 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Why isn't Voltaire mentioned? |
| Muhammad "apparently" had a child with Maria - only 1 sentence, hence "marriage" not "sexual activities" should be mentioned in intro. | 21 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Muhammad "apparently" had a child with Maria - only 1 sentence, hence "marriage" not "sexual activities" should be mentioned in intro. |
| Protected | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Protected |
| Muhammad and the Jews | 7 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Muhammad and the Jews |
| need a response section for each topic in this article | 7 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#need a response section for each topic in this article |
| Ibn Warraq is not reliable | 12 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Ibn Warraq is not reliable |
| Protection | 38 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Protection |
| Slavery after abolition | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Slavery after abolition |
| Fazlur Rahman | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Fazlur Rahman |
| Ibn Ishaq | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Ibn Ishaq |
| How to remove the vandalism? | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#How to remove the vandalism? |
| ref name="Oussani" | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#ref name="Oussani" |
| Why no mention of pedophilia? | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Why no mention of pedophilia? |
| Dubious | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Dubious |
| Standards for criticism articles | 27 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Standards for criticism articles |
| Removal of Haykal | 44 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Removal of Haykal |
| Recent edit warring, protection | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Recent edit warring, protection |
| Cite error | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Cite error |
| Itaqallah's edit | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Itaqallah's edit |
| The "Prophet" Muhammad | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#The "Prophet" Muhammad |
| Aisha and Vines | 5 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Aisha and Vines |
| Gratuitous Off-Topic Rhetoric in Aisha Section | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Gratuitous Off-Topic Rhetoric in Aisha Section |
| Spencer | 12 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Spencer |
| How is the portion about Safiyya bint Huyayy criticism? | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#How is the portion about Safiyya bint Huyayy criticism? |
| Colin Turner quote | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Colin Turner quote |
| Faith Spread by Sword | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 1#Faith Spread by Sword |
| Succinct Delineation of Aisha Critique/NPOV | 9 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Succinct Delineation of Aisha Critique/NPOV |
| Building to Encyclopedic Content | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Building to Encyclopedic Content |
| Anti-Islamic Sentiment Tag | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Anti-Islamic Sentiment Tag |
| Restart | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Restart |
| Carlyle | 5 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Carlyle |
| Other POVs on Aisha's Age | 8 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Other POVs on Aisha's Age |
| Current external link mini editing war | 20 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Current external link mini editing war |
| Aisha | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Aisha |
| Criticism of Muhammad | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Criticism of Muhammad |
| Headings within "Personal Motives" Section | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Headings within "Personal Motives" Section |
| The point of this article | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#The point of this article |
| Mention Hitchens | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Mention Hitchens |
| Greetings | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Greetings |
| Mohamad/Jesus criticism | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Mohamad/Jesus criticism |
| Aishah's age was 19 at marriage time. | 5 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Aishah's age was 19 at marriage time. |
| Mediaeval Arab critic named "Muhammad" | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Mediaeval Arab critic named "Muhammad" |
| Removed Zainab stanza | 6 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Removed Zainab stanza |
| Zaynab bint Jahsh | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Zaynab bint Jahsh |
| Xenophobia | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Xenophobia |
| Source of Criticism move to a separate article or at the bottom of the article | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Source of Criticism move to a separate article or at the bottom of the article |
| Sections Formatting Changes | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Sections Formatting Changes |
| Article Not Appropriate | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Article Not Appropriate |
| Regarding Aisha's Age | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#Regarding Aisha's Age |
| POV, etc. | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#POV, etc. |
| Improper tagging | 7 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 3#Improper tagging |
| reverted deletion of Muhammad images | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 2#reverted deletion of Muhammad images |
| Reverted recent explanation of criticisms | 5 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 3#Reverted recent explanation of criticisms |
| According to Whom | 12 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 3#According to Whom |
| Aisha and the age of marriage in pre industrial world | 23 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 3#Aisha and the age of marriage in pre industrial world |
| Minor versus child | 18 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 3#Minor versus child |
| "Discrimination against women" | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 3#"Discrimination against women" |
| You need reliable secondary sources for criticism | 18 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 4#You need reliable secondary sources for criticism |
| Changing the Title | 31 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 3#Changing the Title |
| Jewish criticism | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 3#Jewish criticism |
| WP:Content noticeboard discussion about this article | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 3#WP:Content noticeboard discussion about this article |
| Suggestion | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 3#Suggestion |
| Ownership of slaves section | 5 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 4#Ownership of slaves section |
| Content Discussion | 8 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 4#Content Discussion |
| Bold, Revert, Discuss versus Edit War | 19 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 4#Bold, Revert, Discuss versus Edit War |
| Likely Sockpuppet | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 4#Likely Sockpuppet |
| Secondary sources for criticism | 54 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 4#Secondary sources for criticism |
| question about the reverts caused by sock puppets and questioning the reliability of criticism | 11 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 4#question about the reverts caused by sock puppets and questioning the reliability of criticism |
| Pictorial representation | 23 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 4#Pictorial representation |
| Inclusion of Danish cartoon which resulted death threats | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Inclusion of Danish cartoon which resulted death threats |
| Where are we At | 12 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Where are we At |
| Removal Of Hate Filled Image | 5 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Removal Of Hate Filled Image |
| Criticism and suggestion | 9 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Criticism and suggestion |
| Jerry Vines | 26 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Jerry Vines |
| Our Religion Is The Religion Of Abraham | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Our Religion Is The Religion Of Abraham |
| Questioning His Psychological And Medical Condition On What Basis | 10 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Questioning His Psychological And Medical Condition On What Basis |
| Perspectives on Muhammad | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Perspectives on Muhammad |
| Muhammad: Only three possibilities | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Muhammad: Only three possibilities |
| Violence? | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Violence? |
| The Marriages of Muhammad | 5 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#The Marriages of Muhammad |
| Tags | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Tags |
| History | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#History |
| Wording | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Wording |
| Film heavily based on Reliable sources not a valid source? | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Film heavily based on Reliable sources not a valid source? |
| Is the 'multiple issues' tag really that necessary? | 18 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Is the 'multiple issues' tag really that necessary? |
| Is this an encyclopedic article? | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Is this an encyclopedic article? |
| Awful. | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Awful. |
| Rangila Rasul | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Rangila Rasul |
| Edit request on 5 November 2012 | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Edit request on 5 November 2012 |
| Biased. | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Biased. |
| Edit Request, 26/03/2013 | 11 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Edit Request, 26/03/2013 |
| Neutrality? | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Neutrality? |
| Scope | 5 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Scope |
| Edit request | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Edit request |
| typo | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#typo |
| dates of critics | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#dates of critics |
| Biased. | 9 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Biased. 2 |
| Aisha - Some modern Muslims sentence | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Aisha - Some modern Muslims sentence |
| Quoting error (wrong number of quotation marks) | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Quoting error (wrong number of quotation marks) |
| External links modified | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#External links modified |
| Who are we talking about | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Who are we talking about |
| Muhammad's wives | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Muhammad's wives |
| "growled like a camel, foamed at his mouth" | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#"growled like a camel, foamed at his mouth" |
| Epilepsy | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 5#Epilepsy |
| Unnecessary edits | 7 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Unnecessary edits |
| A Commons file used on this page has been nominated for deletion | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#A Commons file used on this page has been nominated for deletion |
| What is a primary source and how to tell we are forwarding original research | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#What is a primary source and how to tell we are forwarding original research |
| Discussion about slavery vis-a-vis Muhammad, etc. | 17 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Discussion about slavery vis-a-vis Muhammad, etc. |
| Re: "Unsupported Attribution" for Aisha's age | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Re: "Unsupported Attribution" for Aisha's age |
| A Commons file used on this page has been nominated for deletion | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#A Commons file used on this page has been nominated for deletion 2 |
| Responses to 'criticism' | 7 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Responses to 'criticism' |
| Requesting help in article expansion | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Requesting help in article expansion |
| Semi-protected edit request on 28 October 2020 | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Semi-protected edit request on 28 October 2020 |
| Improving the Article | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Improving the Article |
| Praises of the Prophet Muhammad | 10 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Praises of the Prophet Muhammad |
| Request Edit to Source Information for Thomas Aquinas (1.3.2.1) | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Request Edit to Source Information for Thomas Aquinas (1.3.2.1) |
| Use of primary sources | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Use of primary sources |
| Modern historians | 7 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Modern historians |
| Ref | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Ref |
| Spencer | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Spencer |
| Request approval for following addition on improper sexual conduct with minors in Islamic sources | 36 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Request approval for following addition on improper sexual conduct with minors in Islamic sources |
| Mention of accusations of pedophilia in lead | 35 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Mention of accusations of pedophilia in lead |
| NebulaOblongata blocked | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#NebulaOblongata blocked |
| Recent revert. | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Recent revert. |
| Edit warring on Aisha Section Edits. | 14 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Edit warring on Aisha Section Edits. |
| Reverting recent additions. | 4 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 6#Reverting recent additions. |
| criticism of Mohammed with the divorced wife | 7 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 7#criticism of Mohammed with the divorced wife |
| age of Aisha defence | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 7#age of Aisha defence |
| Does the Quran directly state that Muhammad had 11 wives? | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 7#Does the Quran directly state that Muhammad had 11 wives? |
| Removal of the Kenana section. | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad/Archive 7#Removal of the Kenana section. |
| Sourcing and inconsistency Issues | 2 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad#Sourcing and inconsistency Issues |
| "Clarification Needed: Incorrect Attribution to Karen Armstrong, Book Cited Contradicts the Claim" | 10 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad#"Clarification Needed: Incorrect Attribution to Karen Armstrong, Book Cited Contradicts the Claim" |
| quick question | 3 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad#quick question |
| Muhammad | 1 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad#Muhammad |
| should we add this to aisha section | 8 | Talk:Criticism of Muhammad#should we add this to aisha section |
