- Green indicates clinched playoff berth
- Purple indicates division champion
- Grey indicates best regular season record
| Quarterfinals
| | | Semifinals
| | | ArenaBowl XIII
| |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1
| Tampa Bay
| 19
| | | |
|
| 8
| Orlando
| 41
| |
| | 8
| Orlando
| 48
| |
|
| |
| | | 2
| Iowa
| 41
| |
| 2
| Iowa
| 66
| |
| |
| 7
| Milwaukee
| 34
| |
| | 8
| Orlando
| 48
| |
|
| |
| | | 3
| Albany
| 59
| |
| 3
| Albany
| 55
| | |
| |
| 6
| Grand Rapids
| 45
| |
| | 3
| Albany
| 73
| |
|
| |
| | | 4
| Arizona
| 47
| |
| 4
| Arizona
| 34
| |
| |
| 5
| Nashville
| 30
| |
| Position |
First team |
Second team |
| Quarterback |
Mike Pawlawski, Albany |
Craig Kusick, Grand Rapids |
| Fullback/Linebacker |
Andre Bowden, Tampa Bay |
Bob McMillen, Arizona |
| Wide receiver/Defensive back |
Carlos James, Iowa Darryl Hammond, Nashville |
Melvin Cunningham, Tampa Bay Randy Gatewood, Arizona |
| Wide receiver/Linebacker |
Gary Compton, Milwaukee |
Hunkie Cooper, Arizona |
| Offensive specialist |
Eddie Brown, Albany |
Steve Papin, San Jose |
| Offensive lineman/Defensive lineman |
Robert Stewart, New Jersey James Baron, Nashville Joe Jacobs, Albany |
Jon Krick, Albany Willie Wyatt, Tampa Bay Rich McKenzie, Orlando |
| Defensive specialist |
Cecil Doggette, Arizona Derek Stingley, Albany |
Shea Showers, Iowa Mark Ricks, Portland |
| Kicker |
Mike Black, New England |
Daron Alcorn, Portland |