| Electoral District |
Name |
First elected / previously elected |
| Albert |
Abner R. McClelan |
1854 |
| John Lewis |
1856 |
| Carleton |
Charles Connell |
1846 |
| Charles Perley |
1843, 1856 |
| Charlotte |
Arthur Hill Gillmor |
1854 |
| John McAdam |
1854 |
| James Brown |
1857 |
| James Watson Chandler |
1857 |
| Gloucester |
Joseph Read |
1846, 1856 |
| William End |
1830, 1854 |
| Kent |
Francis McPhelim |
1850 |
| Lestock P. W. DesBrisay |
1856 |
| Kings |
Edwin A. Vail |
1857 |
| Walter B. Scovil |
1856 |
| Matthew McLeod |
1850, 1857 |
| Northumberland |
Richard Sutton |
1854 |
| George Kerr |
1852 |
| Peter Mitchell |
1852, 1856 |
| John M. Johnson |
1850 |
| Queens |
Samuel H. Gilbert |
1852, 1857 |
| John Ferris |
1854 |
| Restigouche |
John McMillan |
1857 |
| John Montgomery |
1846 |
| Saint John City |
Samuel Leonard Tilley |
1850, 1854, 1857 |
| James A. Harding |
1851 |
| Joseph Lawrence (1858) |
1858 |
| Saint John County |
Richard Wright |
1857 |
| John W. Cudlip |
1857 |
| Robert D. Wilmot |
1846 |
| John H. Gray |
1850 |
| Sunbury |
William E. Perley |
1856 |
| David Tapley |
1856 |
| Victoria |
James Tibbits |
1854 |
| Charles Watters |
1855 |
| Westmorland |
Albert J. Smith |
1854 |
| James Steadman |
1854, 1857 |
| Robert K. Gilbert |
1856 |
| Bliss Botsford |
1850, 1856 |
| Daniel Hanington (1857) |
1835, 1857 |
| York |
Charles Macpherson |
1851 |
| John McIntosh |
1857 |
| John C. Allen |
1856 |
| Charles Fisher |
1854 |