| Conf. | | | Overall |
| Team | W | | L | | PCT | | | W | | L | | PCT |
| James Madison † | 13 | – | 5 | | .722 | | | 27 | – | 8
| | .771 |
| Texas State | 13 | – | 5 | | .722 | | | 24 | – | 10
| | .706 |
| Southern Miss | 13 | – | 5 | | .722 | | | 21 | – | 10
| | .677 |
| Georgia Southern | 12 | – | 6 | | .667 | | | 21 | – | 10
| | .677 |
| Old Dominion | 12 | – | 6 | | .667 | | | 22 | – | 13
| | .629 |
| Troy | 12 | – | 6 | | .667 | | | 17 | – | 13
| | .567 |
| Louisiana | 10 | – | 8 | | .556 | | | 22 | – | 21
| | .512 |
| Marshall | 9 | – | 9 | | .500 | | | 17 | – | 14
| | .548 |
| Coastal Carolina | 9 | – | 9 | | .500 | | | 14 | – | 17
| | .452 |
| Arkansas State | 6 | – | 12 | | .333 | | | 13 | – | 19
| | .406 |
| Appalachian State | 6 | – | 12 | | .333 | | | 11 | – | 20
| | .355 |
| Georgia State | 5 | – | 13 | | .278 | | | 12 | – | 21
| | .364 |
| Louisiana–Monroe | 3 | – | 15 | | .167 | | | 7 | – | 23
| | .233 |
| South Alabama | 3 | – | 15 | | .167 | | | 7 | – | 23
| | .233 |
|
† 2023 Sun Belt tournament winner
|
